Close up of admissions campus tour directional sign on public university campus
getty
As August 1st swiftly approaches, rising seniors embark on one of the most challenging tasks in the college admissions process: writing the personal statement.
This 650-word essay has long presented students with the unique challenge of conveying their authentic story and personality to admissions committees in 650 words or less. While writing the college essay has always required ingenuity, originality, and creative thinking, students in today’s admissions landscape face the particularly daunting task of distinguishing their voice from the explosion of AI-generated writing. Recent studies have shown that the proliferation of AI writing has led to increasingly homogenized language in college essays, language which correlates with higher rates of rejection amongst students who use it. In other words, students must not only show how their experiences and qualities are distinct from thousands of other applicants, but they must do so in language and diction that separates them from the crowd, as well.
Some parents may assume that the solution to this problem is simple: students who don’t use AI for their essays will stand out from those who do. But as AI-generated language becomes increasingly ubiquitous, many students are implicitly developing a writing style that bears all of the trademarks of AI writing, even if they are not relying on large language models to write on their behalf. Every time a student turns to a large language model for summaries, information, or research, they inevitably internalize the structures, language, and cadence of the bot, and many unwittingly reproduce them in their own writing.
College Essay Support is Not the Same as 10 Years Ago
What this means is that college essay support for students today looks dramatically different than it did ten years ago. A decade ago, the role of an essay counselor was largely confined to brainstorming topics, tightening structure, and polishing grammar in the final weeks before deadlines.
Today, it is no longer sufficient to enlist hands-off editorial support in the final stages of writing. More targeted and intentional support is needed to cultivate a student’s genuine voice and develop a more sophisticated understanding of writing style. Students in today’s AI landscape require personalized, remedial guidance to unlearn the habits that algorithmic AI language has instilled in them and to rediscover the idiosyncrasies that make their writing their own.
The most effective support begins months in advance, with an emphasis on rebuilding a student’s relationship to their own voice before a single draft is written. This often entails returning to fundamentals: reading widely and critically, freewriting without the aid of any digital tool, and practicing specific, innovative forms of writing that AI-generated prose tends to obscure in generic and abstract language. Only when a student has reconnected with their authentic style can the more traditional work of brainstorming and revision truly begin.
What to Look for in College Essay Support
Given how much the landscape has shifted, families should be discerning about the kind of support they seek out as their child embarks on the college application process. Not all essay coaching is created equal, especially as the qualities that mattered most a decade ago are not necessarily the ones that matter most now.
With this in mind, families should look for an essay coach that empowers students to cultivate their authentic voice over superficial polish. An advisor who prioritizes line-editing over helping a student truly understand writing structures and articulate what makes their perspective distinct is treating the symptom rather than the root cause of many students’ essay-writing struggles. A strong coach asks probing questions, pushes students to sit with discomfort and ambiguity, and encourages them to continue brainstorming and refining rather than settling with their first idea. Most importantly, in an era of essays that have been airbrushed by AI, an exceptional writing coach will resist the urge to smooth over the very idiosyncrasies that make an essay memorable and distinct.
Families should also prioritize longevity and consistency. Because developing a student’s genuine voice requires time, one-off sessions or last-minute proofreading services are far less effective than sustained mentorship that spans multiple months. The counselors who understand a student’s story, values, and speech patterns are uniquely equipped to help them, since they can quickly recognize when a sentence sounds more like a chatbot (or a parent) than the student themselves. Ultimately, the students who write the most compelling essays are rarely those who receive a few rounds of edits in July; they are the students who have spent the better part of a year developing self-awareness, honing their craft, and learning to trust their own perspective.
Finally, the strongest advisors will take a holistic approach to writing coaching. Becoming a stronger writer is not a formulaic task; it requires students to read widely, seek out inspiration, and think critically about language. The more a coach can guide students to think outside of the box and view writing as an art rather than a science, the better their essays will become.
Seeking out exceptional support can offer benefits that reach far beyond the college application process. As the vast majority of students find themselves unprepared for the demands of college-level writing, investing in high-level support not only equips students to stand out to admissions officers, but also to quickly begin honing the skills they will need in the college classroom. Rather than viewing college applications as a transactional process or a task-list to complete, students should approach the process as a journey of self-discovery and an opportunity to articulate, perhaps for the first time, who they really are.
The essay-writing process offers a rare invitation for students to slow down and reflect on their experiences while intentionally honing their voice. The students who receive strategic support during this process don’t just gain an edge in the applicant pool, but also a clearer sense of their own identity that will carry them long after the acceptance letters arrive.
